Skip to main content

Hair of the Dogma: Why Atheists are Dangerous Fundamentalists


I’m always suspicious of anyone who professes an absolute philosophy.

If you tell me that God exists with absolute certainty then I’m afraid I have to question your dogma. But on the other hand, if you tell me you believe in the existence of a benign higher power, I respect your right to believe in such, particularly if it gives you hope and optimism.

By the same token, if you sit there and tell me that it is a matter of absolute fact that God (whoever she might be) doesn’t exist, then frankly, you are every bit as much of a donkey as any Alabama Creationist or hatred-inciting Imam.

Usually, our secular bredrin who unyieldingly profess atheism, rely on science to show us how absurd it is to believe in the existence of a supreme deity.  

In their efforts to ridicule faith which they usually conflate with organised religion, these advocates of the scientific approach usually pick soft targets such as the aforementioned creationists or reliquaries such as the Turin Shroud which can be forensically discounted by dinosaur fossils and carbon dating.

However, I was recently struck by how poorly science serves us in terms of offering a grand unifying theory of life, the universe and everything (or even simple empirical certainty for that matter).

While I don’t propose to offer a treatise on Relativity and quantum mechanics (a task for which I would be sorely ill-equipped), I can’t help wondering nevertheless about the absurdity of some of the ideas we are being asked to contemplate in the name of physics.

Let’s look at the idiosyncratic improbability of singularities for openers; why is the concept of infinite mass  occupying precisely no space whatsoever at the centre of a black hole any less implausible than believing in the existence of a man who looked like Che Guevara turning water into wine 2000 years ago?

It would appear that the Physics community has been having something of a crisis for quite some time now and it’s down to the fact that – try as they might – physicists cannot reconcile the world of the quantum (ie the infinitesimally tiny) with the realm of the gargantuan which is governed by the gravity and relativity.  The rules governing both seem to break down when presented with black holes and as a consequence, science came up with the idea of singularities.

Now, as far as I’m concerned, a singularity makes about as much sense as counting the angels dancing on the head of a pin but still this is taken as a preferable explanation to that of the more mystically inclined among us.

The high-profile exponents of atheism, the Christopher Hitchens and Richard Dawkins of this world, are every bit as dogmatic in defence of their belief system (which generally turns out to be dispassionate and ruthlessly Darwinian) as any Catholic theologian.

As a rhetorical emotive sop to their followers, these people never tire of reminding us that many of the world’s ills have been propagated by organised religion. This is true; child abuse and its cover-up in the Roman Church, fundamentalist Protestant intolerance and many wars and crusades, right up to the present day, have their roots in the application and misapplication of principles derived from organised religion.

While these things are undoubtedly evil (in the old school sense of the word), the dominant secular philosophy of our age – capitalism – is responsible for much greater and more enduring inequality and suffering. The freedoms professed by Dawkins and Hitchens have been used to create a global inequity that leaves a tiny minority controlling the vast majority of wealth.

Taking for a moment the devil’s advocate approach: organised religion comes with a lot of baggage but I can’t believe for a second that the secular philosophy of capital would offer mass education in the way that it was given by Christianity. Would capitalism have nurtured knowledge for the masses in the same way as Islam or Judaism if the cost benefit analysis didn’t pan out?

When Christopher Hitchens joined the choir invisible, how quickly his liberal mourners forgot his support for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. His secular 'canonisation' was a hypocritical volte face that the Hitler Youth Pope would be proud of.

But to conclude, I would return to the start and adopt a rational and secular approach. The existence of God has never been a matter of science, it has always been a matter of faith. Faith is not rational, nor should it be. It is not governed by the laws of physics (which are themselves apparently largely a matter of faith).

‘God’ is not an empirical entity; therefore trying to disprove her existence shows such a fundamental lack of understanding of the nature of deity that it is, of itself, a dangerous and ignorant business often driven more by dogma, personal enmity and disillusionment than by rational philosophical inquiry.

‘I don’t know what God is but I know it doesn’t exist...’ It’s hardly the enlightened way forward is it?

Comments

  1. To acclaim greater knowledge I would imagine that we should see beyond the boundries that are set . If we can imagine it we can make it , This in a spiritual matter is perhaps the same . If one was to imagine that there are a myriad of unending and different universes thus an unending and infinite way of percieving the truth as an individual . If we were to live with this tolerance for a vaster and more fulfilling challenge then maybe we would have an oppertunity to go beyond these boundries which are more or less held in our heads and hearts as a comfort . Fine some stay within this comfort zone others may take up the challenge and cross new frontiers in trying to study and understand the workings of the world seen with human eyes . I agree that there are no absolutes . The truth is forever changing and without change well the story gets boring . Perhaps "GOD" does fly a flying saucer as time in the universe and beyond is much slower when flying at the speed of light or perhaps "GOD" is of such a spiritual substance unknown to mankind and all we`r diong is filling in the blanks .One thing is for certain if there is a "GOD" as I truly believe there is She must have a real good sense of humor . People throughout generations have been baffled with the divine and no one has a reasonable answer .I can imagine "GOD" and the other dietys having a rumbling laugh sitting in their kitchen with a pitcher of beer spilling drying there eyes and drinking to our guess work . Putting a wager on as to who might even get close to the infallible truth . It`s is ridicoulus in sight of the imaginable that any dogma would even bring us nearer to a unified understanding .

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Down a Rabbit-Hole

Please allow me to introduce myself. My name is Seán Flynn. I'm 56 years old and I have been a front-line paramedic with the London Ambulance Service in the East End for the past seven years. It's a job I love and, by and large, it's the happiest I've been in a long and varied working life. I am also an accredited GAA (Gaelic Athletic Association) coach with enhanced DBS clearance; both as a coach and as a registered clinician. I recently travelled to the West Bank in order to coach three teams in the territory under the aegis of GAA Palestine, introducing the children to Gaelic football. I was lucky enough to travel first to South Bethlehem, then to the Al Am'ari Refugee Camp in Ramallah and then on to Qabatya in Jenin. It's important to note at this point however that the individual with whom I was initially due to travel, pulled out on the morning of the trip as the result of a cancelled connecting flight; leaving me to fly out on my own.  As a consequ...

Never thought my life would be like this

    When I wake up on a work day (it doesn't matter whether it's early or late), I get on station and figure out which truck I'm on; there's a screen in the mess room that shows the fleet number – my truck – beside mine and my crewmate's names and our call-sign for the shift. I go to the key safe, use the appropriate code and take out the keys matching the fleet number (assuming that the keys don't belong to a truck still out on the road). Then I go to the drugs room, using my ID card to gain entrance. Inside, I use a specially allocated smart key to gain access to the drugs lockers to take out my meds for the shift. I then have to separately access another safe to get my morphine ampoules which I have to sign out and have witnessed. I also have to ensure that the numbers between the book and safe tally before closing the safe. So once I have my drugs, I go back to my truck and start to check it over. Engine, and all lights (incl. hazards and blues) on for a wal...

A Deptford Particular

Earlier this month and for the last time, I trained at the Lord Clyde Boxing Gym in Deptford. When it closed, I lost one of my favourite places in all of London. The gym at the ‘Clyde shut its doors after a protracted legal battle that had initially seen the plucky little boozer successfully challenge the developers’ plans. Landlord Rory McInally brought together a wide coalition to oppose the move. But the developers have since hit back and have succeeded in their objections to the gym’s continued use. This was a place where local kids boxed for free, trained and supervised by former professional boxers fer chrissakes. Plans had even been afoot to revive the Cuban-style outdoor gym in the backyard for the Summer months. While we’re not always the biggest fans of the police on these pages we do acknowledge that those officers who have any interest in building community relations have always traditionally recognised the value  of local boxing gyms and the ‘Clyde had ...