![]() |
| Logo: can't say whose.... |
It was surely pushing on an open door for both the Tories and the Lib Dems that these measures were untenable in light of their well-documented pre-election scepticism, not to mention recent House of Lords judicial rulings.
As far back as June 2009, the demise of the discredited control order regime for terror suspects was being predicted after a significant ruling by the law lords which posited that it was unlawful to use "secret evidence" to place people under a regime that includes a 16-hour curfew.
Nine judges led by the senior law lord Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers ruled unanimously that was a fundamental principle that everyone was entitled to the disclosure of sufficient material to enable them to answer effectively the case made against them.
![]() |
| Chakrabarti |
Shami Chakrabarti, the director of Liberty, has gone on the record saying: "Condemnation of control orders from civil liberties organisations across the world shows just what an international embarrassment they have become. Punishment without charge or trial is the trademark of despots. A government that has wrapped itself in the language of liberty cannot allow this regime to continue..."
The orders came into force in 2005 and they replaced detention without trial of terrorist suspects (fondly remembered as internment in Ireland), which the House of Lords ruled was a breach of human rights. Nine suspects are currently under control orders according to the Daily Telegraph.
Meanwhile, the Intelligence service, since the 2005 introduction of control orders, seems to have amused itself by continuously giving mixed messages on what it thought about the control orders. Here’s just a couple of pronouncements they have made or leaked to the press since November:
![]() |
| New bag-opening powers needed... |
Only six weeks previously, a high-profile speech by the director-general of MI5, Jonathan Evans, appeared to call for the government to maintain the policy of putting terror suspects under house arrest without trial.
Then the Daily Telegraph reported today that “Jonathan Evans, the head of MI5, wrote to David Cameron, the Prime Minister, two weeks ago to warn that he could not guarantee that suspects currently under control orders would not resume plotting against this country if freed.”
Well, if the British Intelligence services can’t get their ducks in a row on where they are with control orders, perhaps they might look to a jurisdiction where they might at least be expected to have gleaned some knowledge of how to conduct a covert war.
![]() |
| Clegg: Pantomime horse's ass |
The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (An independent, all-Ireland Civil Rights Watchdog) has gone on the record "deploring the persistence of the use of control orders in the United Kingdom".
It goes on to stress that "in any area, such as the island of Ireland, which has lived with the corrosive effects of terrorism, it has become abundantly clear that applying measures of this sort does nothing to increase the safety of the general population. On the contrary, the mere existence of prolonged forms of detention without trial itself becomes a rallying point for those who wish to recruit people minded to subvert democracy."
The British intelligence service really doesn’t need more powers in the war on terror, it just needs to apply itself properly to the already too extensive powers at its disposal...
The reality of Clegg’s public relations victory may well be a replacement system which could involve much greater use of surveillance to keep tabs on terror suspects. Doubtless this would lead to bigger budgets for the security services in the form of costs running to hundreds of thousands of pounds a year for each suspect kept under round-the-clock surveillance.




Comments
Post a Comment